Contesting a Will in Florida: Why You Need a Florida Probate Litigation Attorney

Contesting a will in Florida can be a complex and emotional process. Whether you’re a disinherited beneficiary or concerned about the legitimacy of a loved one’s last will and testament, understanding your rights and legal options under Florida law is essential. This guide walks you through the process of challenging a will in Florida, highlights common legal grounds, explains the role of a probate attorney, and answers key questions regarding costs, success rates, and probate court procedures.

These are serious legal proceedings with high stakes and strict deadlines, so you need to act quickly and hire an attorney if you believe you have valid legal reasons to proceed. Contesting a will in Florida typically involves allegations such as undue influence, lack of testamentary capacity, improper execution, or fraud. A Florida probate litigation attorney will analyze the will, gather evidence, and file formal objections within the statutory timeframe—often just 90 days from notice of administration.

Successfully challenging a will in Florida depends on the strength of your legal grounds and the evidence available to support your claim. A skilled Florida probate litigation attorney can assess the merits of your case, guide you through mediation or court hearings, and protect your interests during this high-stakes litigation process.

What is the Success Rate of Contesting a Will in Florida?

Factors Affecting the Success Rate

The success rate of contesting a will in Florida depends heavily on the specific facts of the case. The most significant factors include the strength of the evidence, the legal grounds for the contest, and the ability to demonstrate that the will is invalid under Florida law. Key considerations include:

Whether the testator had the mental capacity to execute the will and was of sound mind
Presence of undue influence by a beneficiary or other party, or an undue influencer
Compliance with Florida statute 732.502 regarding will execution
Availability of witnesses to testify about the testator’s condition or surrounding circumstances

Statistics on Florida Will Contests

Reliable statistics on Florida will contests are difficult to obtain. Many of these cases settle confidentially before reaching trial, and there is no centralized reporting agency that tracks the outcomes of contested probate proceedings across the state. As a result, exact success rates are largely anecdotal and depend on individual case circumstances. The outcome often hinges on the quality of the legal representation and the strength of the evidence presented.

Common Outcomes in Probate Court

Typical outcomes in Florida probate litigation include:

The will is upheld, and the challenge is dismissed
The will is partially revoked or modified
The court invalidates the will and applies intestacy laws, causing the estate due to intestacy laws to be distributed accordingly
A settlement is reached among the parties before trial

What is the Cost of Contesting a Will in Florida?

Understanding Legal Fees and Expenses

The cost of contesting a will in Florida varies depending on the complexity of the case and the law firm representing the contesting party. Some probate attorneys charge hourly rates, while others may offer flat fees or contingency arrangements. Standard legal expenses include:

Court filing fees
Attorney’s fees
Expert witness fees (e.g., medical or handwriting experts)
Deposition and discovery costs

Factors Influencing the Overall Cost

Costs can rise quickly in contested probate cases, especially if the matter proceeds to trial. Influential cost factors include:

The number of parties involved
Length of discovery and litigation
Need for expert testimony
Complexity of the estate plan and legal documents

Potential Costs vs. Benefits of Contesting

Before you decide to contest a will in Florida, weigh the costs against the potential inheritance at stake. A Florida probate attorney can help you assess whether pursuing the case is financially and strategically wise. Remember, losing a will contest may result in being disinherited under a “no-contest” clause, though such clauses are generally unenforceable under Florida law.

What Are the Grounds for Contesting a Will in Florida?

Undue Influence and Its Impact

Undue influence is one of the most common legal grounds for contesting a will in Florida. It occurs when a person exerts improper pressure on the testator, overpowering their free will. According to Florida case law, a presumption of undue influence arises when:

A substantial beneficiary had a confidential relationship with the testator
The beneficiary was active in procuring the will

These are common reasons why someone may challenge a will based on undue influence.

Mental Capacity Requirements for a Valid Will

To execute a valid will under Florida statute 732.501, the testator must have testamentary capacity. This means the testator must:

Understand the nature and extent of their assets
Know the natural objects of their bounty (heirs or beneficiaries)
Comprehend the effect of signing the will

Evidence of dementia, Alzheimer’s, or other mental impairments may support a claim that the testator lacked capacity at the time of execution, particularly if the death of the testator occurred shortly thereafter.

Other Legal Grounds for Contesting

In addition to undue influence and lack of mental capacity, Florida law permits contesting a will on several other legal grounds. These challenges often arise in emotionally charged family situations, particularly when a will significantly departs from expectations or disinherits close relatives. Whether you are challenging a will in Florida or defending against a contest, it is crucial to understand the legal basis for such claims and the role a Florida probate litigation attorney plays in the process.

Grounds for Contesting a Will in Florida

There are multiple legal theories under which an interested party can initiate a will contest. The most common include:

1. Fraud or Forgery
A will may be invalidated if it was procured through fraudulent means. This could involve a person intentionally misleading the testator about key facts to influence their testamentary decisions. For example, someone may lie about another beneficiary’s actions or character to have them disinherited. Forgery is a separate but related ground, involving situations where the will or the testator’s signature was fabricated or altered without authorization. In both scenarios, a Florida probate litigation attorney will be essential in gathering handwriting experts, presenting testimony, and proving the deceptive conduct that tainted the will’s authenticity.

2. Improper Execution or Lack of Witnesses
Florida Statutes require specific formalities for a will to be valid. It must be signed by the testator at the end of the document in the presence of two witnesses, who must also sign in the presence of each other and the testator. If these procedures weren’t followed—such as a missing witness signature or failure to observe each other sign—the will may be declared invalid. Contesting a will in Florida on this basis often involves testimony from witnesses, notaries, or even video footage, if available.

3. Revocation by a Later Will
If the decedent executed a later will that revokes the prior one, and the newer will was properly executed and remains valid, the older will is typically unenforceable. Florida recognizes revocation by physical act (e.g., tearing up the will) or by a written subsequent will that clearly expresses the intent to revoke prior documents. A Florida probate litigation attorney can help locate any newer instruments, contest or defend their validity, and litigate which version of the will controls.

4. Mistake or Ambiguity
Sometimes, the will’s language may contain mistakes, inconsistencies, or vague provisions that lead to disputes. A will might include incorrect beneficiary names, contradicting clauses, or unclear asset designations. These ambiguities can result in litigation over the testator’s intent. Florida courts generally will not allow extrinsic evidence to contradict a clearly worded will, but in cases of latent or patent ambiguity, a court may allow further inquiry to clarify the testator’s true wishes.

Importance of Legal Counsel

Each of these grounds for challenging a will in Florida involves strict procedural requirements and evidentiary burdens. You must have legal standing—meaning you are either an heir under intestacy or a beneficiary under a prior or competing will—and you must act quickly, as Florida imposes short deadlines to file a formal objection once notice of administration is served. Failure to timely object can result in the forfeiture of your right to contest the will.

Hiring an experienced Florida probate litigation attorney is essential. Your attorney will:

Evaluate the facts and evidence supporting your claim or defense
Draft and file the necessary court pleadings
Conduct discovery to obtain key documents and testimony
Represent you in probate court hearings or trial
Advise on settlement options or mediation

Contesting a will in Florida is not a matter to be taken lightly. These are high-stakes legal disputes that often determine the fate of substantial assets, family legacies, and real estate. If you believe a will is legally defective or that your rights have been disregarded, a skilled Florida probate litigation attorney can guide you through the process and help you achieve the best possible outcome.

How to Challenge a Will in Florida

Steps to File a Will Contest in Florida

Challenging a will in Florida is a legal process that requires precision, planning, and swift action. If you believe a loved one’s will is invalid—whether due to undue influence, lack of capacity, fraud, or improper execution—you must follow specific legal procedures to initiate a challenge. Below is a detailed breakdown of the steps involved in contesting a will in Florida, along with the critical role of a Florida probate litigation attorney throughout the process.

1. Hire a Florida Probate Litigation Attorney

Before taking any formal action, you must retain an experienced Florida probate litigation attorney who focuses on estate disputes. Probate litigation is highly specialized, with strict rules of procedure and evidence. Your attorney will evaluate the situation, assess your legal standing, and help you determine whether a viable legal basis exists for the will contest.

2. Review the Will and Supporting Documents

Your attorney will obtain a copy of the will from the probate court (or personal representative) and analyze it for legal defects. Other important documents may include prior wills, medical records, trust instruments, and correspondence that may reveal undue influence, fraud, or confusion about the decedent’s true intentions.

3. File a Formal Lawsuit in Probate Court

Contesting a will in Florida is not just an objection—it is a formal lawsuit filed within the probate case. The complaint must state the grounds for the challenge (e.g., undue influence, fraud, lack of capacity) and be filed within the statutory deadline, typically 90 days after receiving notice of administration. If you miss this deadline, you forfeit your right to contest.

4. Gather Evidence to Support the Challenge

This is where your attorney’s litigation skills come into play. Successfully challenging a will in Florida often involves:

Witness interviews and sworn affidavits
Medical and psychiatric records of the decedent
Financial documents showing suspicious transfers
Expert testimony from doctors or handwriting analysts

5. Participate in Discovery and Prepare for Trial or Mediation

Both sides will engage in discovery—depositions, interrogatories, and document requests. Most cases settle before trial, but your attorney must be ready to litigate aggressively if needed. Mediation may be ordered by the court, providing a chance to resolve the matter without prolonged litigation.

Filing a will contest in Florida is not a simple formality—it is a serious legal proceeding with real consequences for the estate and the beneficiaries. A knowledgeable Florida probate litigation attorney will ensure your case is filed timely, supported by strong evidence, and strategically positioned for the best possible result in or out of court.

Important Deadlines to Consider

Under Florida law, a party who wishes to contest the validity of a will must file a petition or other pleading in the probate court within 3 months (90 days) after service of the Notice of Administration.

Form: A formal petition or other pleading must be filed.
Extension: This deadline may only be extended by estoppel if the personal representative misstates the time period.
Absolute Bar: All objections are permanently barred after 1 year from service or upon the entry of final discharge of the personal representative—whichever occurs first. If a formal notice is provided before probate begins, the deadline may be reduced to 20 days. These are the critical days to contest a will in Florida.

In certain situations, you may request that the court revoke an already admitted will. If successful, the court may revoke or deem the will invalid and proceed according to intestacy laws or another valid instrument.

Choosing the Right Contest Attorney

Hiring the right Florida probate litigation attorney can make or break your case. Look for an experienced estate and probate attorney who:

Specializes in Florida estate law
Has a track record in probate litigation
Offers transparent billing practices
Is prepared to take the matter to trial if necessary

Common Questions About Contesting a Will in Florida

Who Can Contest a Will?

According to Florida law, only individuals with legal standing can challenge a will. This typically includes:

Heirs at law who would inherit under intestacy
Beneficiaries named in a prior will
Creditors of the estate
Any party who may be eligible to inherit the estate under Florida intestacy law

What Is the Legal Process for Contesting?

The legal process for contesting a will in Florida includes:

Filing a petition with the probate court
Notifying all interested parties
Engaging in pretrial discovery
Attending court hearings or mediation
Receiving a court ruling or negotiated settlement

Florida has a specific process for handling these disputes under its probate code. These are formal legal proceedings governed by detailed procedural rules.

What Happens After Filing a Will Contest?

Once the contest is filed, the personal representative (also known as the executor) must defend the will. The court may order discovery, depositions, or medical evaluations. Eventually, the case will either settle or proceed to trial, where the judge may revoke or deem the will invalid. The person challenging the will may inherit the estate due to intestacy laws if the court determines the will to be invalid.

Why You Need a Florida Probate Litigation Attorney for Will Contests

Benefits of Hiring an Experienced Probate Litigation Attorney

The probate process is governed by complex statutes and procedures. An experienced Florida probate attorney can help you:

File all legal documents correctly and on time
Develop a compelling legal strategy
Navigate probate proceedings and rules of evidence
Negotiate favorable settlements
Avoid common pitfalls that may harm your case

How a Probate Lawyer Can Assist You

Whether you want to contest a will or defend against a contest, a skilled probate lawyer can:

Analyze the will and supporting evidence
Evaluate your standing and likelihood of success
Handle communications with other parties and the probate court
Represent your interests in mediation or trial

An estate litigation lawyer can also help you determine whether you’re entitled to a share of the estate and evaluate the legal reasons available for contesting the will. Contesting a will in Florida requires a clear understanding of the legal procedures and deadlines involved. A Florida probate litigation attorney will assess whether the will was properly executed under Florida law and whether issues such as undue influence, fraud, or lack of mental capacity may apply. These cases often require medical records, witness testimony, and forensic evidence to build a compelling case.

If you’re considering challenging a will in Florida, you must act quickly—once probate is initiated, the clock starts ticking. A Florida probate litigation attorney can file the appropriate objections, handle all procedural requirements, and aggressively advocate on your behalf. Whether you’re an heir who’s been wrongfully excluded or a beneficiary seeking to uphold a valid will, legal representation is critical in protecting your rights and navigating this high-stakes process.

Ask ChatGPT

Choosing the Right Law Firm for Your Case

When selecting a law firm to represent you in a Florida will contest, it’s essential to choose one with the knowledge and experience to navigate complex issues involved in contesting wills. The firm should:

Is a Florida Probate Litigation Attorney who has gone to trial
Focus on estate planning and probate litigation
Be familiar with local probate courts and judges
Have experience handling similar disputes over undue influence or mental capacity
Provide strong client reviews and testimonials

A Florida estate litigation lawyer will understand the intricacies of contested cases in Florida and be equipped to advise you according to the specific rules and practices of the state of Florida. If you’re dealing with legal concerns related to the validity of a will or probate process, discussing your legal concerns with a knowledgeable attorney can help clarify your position and next steps.

Whether you’re considering litigation or already involved in a dispute, the right firm will offer strategic guidance tailored to your situation. They will be prepared to handle contested cases efficiently and give you the legal support you need to protect your rights and your potential share of the estate.

Summary: Key Takeaways on Contesting a Will in Florida

Contesting a will in Florida is a serious legal undertaking requiring knowledge of probate law and evidence collection.
Grounds for contesting include undue influence, lack of mental capacity, fraud, and improper execution.
The cost of contesting a will in Florida can vary widely and should be weighed against potential inheritance.
Success rates are relatively low but improve with strong evidence and experienced legal counsel.
You must act quickly, usually within 90 days of receiving the Notice of Administration.
Only parties with legal standing may file a will contest.
A Florida probate litigation attorney can guide you through the legal process, protect your rights, and increase your chances of success.

Contact Us Today to Learn More About Our Process Assisting Probate Clients

If you’re contesting a Florida will or are involved in an estate matter contested in Florida, we’re here to help. I will listen carefully to your reasons for contesting the will and provide you with the most accurate and strategic assessment possible.

Click the button below to connect with an experienced Florida probate litigation attorney who can address your legal concerns and help you with this difficult process. We look forward to hearing from you and assisting in every way we can.

Contesting a Will in Florida? Florida Probate Litigation