Contesting a Will in Florida: A Comprehensive Guide

Why You Need a Florida Probate Litigation Attorney

Time is not on your side. Under Florida’s state laws, you typically have just 90 days from the Notice of Administration to file a will challenge—miss this deadline, and you may lose your right to contest forever.

When Contesting a Will in Florida, understanding the legal grounds and procedural requirements is critical, which is why working with experienced counsel is essential from the very beginning.

Whether you are a family member who believes a loved one’s wishes were manipulated, an interested person named in a previous will, or someone concerned about the will’s validity, understanding your rights and acting quickly is essential to protecting your inheritance.

The relevant Florida statute—such as Florida Statutes Section 732.518—governs the validity and contesting of wills, outlining the legal framework for these disputes.

Successfully pursuing a will contest case requires specific legal grounds, substantial evidence, and strict adherence to procedural deadlines.

A will challenge involves formal legal action filed in probate court, and the outcome determines how the decedent’s estate is distributed among the involved parties.

A Florida probate litigation attorney can evaluate the merits of your case, advise you on strategy, and represent your interests throughout the litigation process.

When selecting a law firm, it is crucial to choose one experienced in contesting wills, with proven expertise in estate litigation and Florida-specific probate procedures.

If you believe a deceased person’s final wishes were not properly reflected in their will, or that the document was procured through fraud or coercion, legal counsel can help you determine the best path forward.

Why Work With an Experienced Estate Planning Law Firm?

When dealing with a loved one’s will, the complexity of probate law can be overwhelming. While an estate planning attorney typically focuses on drafting documents to avoid conflict, a law firm that handles litigation is necessary when a dispute arises.

Navigating the probate process requires a deep understanding of how Florida courts interpret the language within a legal document.

By working with an experienced estate litigation team, you ensure that the parties involved are held to the strict standards required by the state.

What Is the Success Rate of Contesting a Will in Florida?

Factors That Influence Your Chances

The success rate of contesting a will in Florida varies significantly based on the circumstances of each case.

There is no centralized database tracking the outcomes of will contest cases across the state, and many disputes settle confidentially before reaching trial. However, certain factors consistently affect whether a challenge will succeed.

How hard is it to win a will contest in Florida? While no attorney can guarantee a win, cases with documented medical evidence of incapacity or clear proof of active procurement (undue influence) have a significantly higher success rate.

The strength of your substantial evidence is paramount. Courts require more than speculation or family member disagreements to invalidate a will.

You must demonstrate through medical records, witness testimony, financial documents, or expert analysis that the will fails to meet legal requirements or was improperly procured.

Another critical factor is whether the testator had the mental capacity to execute the will.

This means the deceased person understood the nature and extent of their property, knew who their natural heirs were, and comprehended the legal effect of signing the document.

Evidence of dementia, Alzheimer’s disease, or other cognitive impairments at the time of the will signing ceremony can support a lack of capacity claim.

The presence of undue influence claims also significantly impacts outcomes.

If you can show that a beneficiary exploited a confidential relationship with the testator and was actively involved in procuring the will, Florida law may presume undue influence occurred. This shifts the burden to the proponent of the will to prove otherwise.

Common Outcomes in Florida Will Contests

Will contest cases in Florida typically resolve in one of several ways. The court may uphold the challenged will and dismiss the contest entirely.

Alternatively, the will may be partially invalidated, with certain provisions revoked while others remain in effect.

In some cases, the court invalidates the entire will, causing the decedent’s estate to pass according to intestacy laws or a previous will that was properly executed.

Many cases settle before trial through negotiation or mediation among the involved parties.

Settlement allows family members to resolve disputes without the expense and emotional toll of prolonged litigation.

An experienced attorney can help you evaluate settlement offers and determine whether accepting a negotiated resolution serves your interests better than proceeding to trial.

What Does It Cost to Contest a Will in Florida?

Understanding Legal Fees and Expenses

The cost of contesting a will in Florida depends on the complexity of the case, the amount of discovery required, and whether the matter proceeds to trial.

Probate litigation attorneys may charge hourly rates, flat fees for specific tasks, or contingency arrangements where fees depend on the outcome.

Attorney fees are a significant part of the overall cost, and legal fees for contesting a will can range from $250 to $1,000 per hour depending on location.

You should discuss fee structures with your contest lawyer during the initial consultation.

Standard expenses in a will contest case include court filing fees, attorney’s fees, expert witness fees for medical or handwriting analysis, deposition costs, and document production expenses.

If the case involves multiple wills or complex estate planning documents, additional time and resources may be required to analyze and compare the instruments.

Weighing Costs Against Potential Recovery

Before initiating legal action, carefully consider whether the potential inheritance justifies the litigation costs. A Florida probate litigation attorney can help you assess the realistic value of your claim and the likelihood of success.

If the decedent’s estate is relatively small, the costs of litigation may consume a significant portion of any recovery.

Florida law generally does not enforce “no-contest” clauses that attempt to disinherit beneficiaries who challenge a will, so you typically will not lose your existing inheritance simply by filing a contest.

However, unsuccessful litigation can strain family relationships and deplete estate assets through legal fees paid by both sides.

What Are the Grounds for Contesting a Will in Florida?

Florida law requires specific legal grounds to contest a will’s validity. Assessing the will’s validity is a crucial step in probate court, as the court must determine whether the will meets all legal standards before it can be admitted.

General dissatisfaction with how assets were distributed or disagreements among family members are not sufficient bases for a challenge.

You must establish that the will fails to meet legal requirements or was improperly executed or procured.

The relevant Florida statute, such as Florida Statute § 732.5165, outlines the grounds for contesting a will, including fraud, duress, mistake, or undue influence.

Undue Influence

Undue influence is among the most frequently asserted grounds in Florida will contests. It occurs when someone exerts improper pressure on the testator, substituting their own wishes for those of the deceased person.

Under Florida case law, a presumption of undue influence arises when a substantial beneficiary had a confidential relationship with the testator and was active in procuring the will.

Evidence supporting undue influence claims may include testimony from witnesses who observed the relationship between the testator and the alleged influencer.

It may also include documentation showing the beneficiary controlled access to the testator or proof that the will’s provisions sharply deviated from the testator’s prior estate plans or expressed intentions.

Signs of isolation, where the influencer separated the testator from other family members, are particularly compelling.

Financial records showing unusual transfers or changes in account access may also support these claims.

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

A valid will requires that the testator possessed sufficient mental capacity at the time of execution.

The testator must have understood the nature and extent of their property, known the natural objects of their bounty, and comprehended what it meant to make a will.

Medical records, testimony from treating physicians, and observations from family members and caregivers can all serve as substantial evidence of incapacity.

Capacity is evaluated at the specific moment the will was signed, not at other times. Even individuals with dementia may have lucid intervals during which they possess sufficient capacity to execute a valid will.

Conversely, someone who appeared competent in daily life may have lacked capacity due to medication effects, illness, or other factors present during the will signing ceremony.

Fraud and Forgery

A will procured through fraud is invalid under Florida law. Fraud may involve intentionally deceiving the testator about material facts to influence their testamentary decisions.

For example, someone might falsely tell the testator that a child has died or has committed serious wrongdoing to cause disinheritance. Forgery involves fabricating the testator’s signature or altering the document without authorization.

Proving fraud or forgery typically requires expert testimony from handwriting analysts, forensic document examiners, or other specialists.

Your contest lawyer will work with these experts to build a compelling case demonstrating that the will does not reflect the testator’s genuine intent.

Courts take these allegations seriously, and successful fraud or forgery claims can result in complete invalidation of the will and potential criminal referrals for the perpetrators.

Identifying Improper Execution of a Last Will

One of the most straightforward ways to challenge a last will is by proving improper execution. Under Florida law, a last will and testament must be signed by a testator of sound mind in the presence of at least two witnesses.

These witnesses must also sign the document in the presence of the testator and each other.

If witness signatures are missing, forged, or were not gathered according to the legal process, the court may find the document invalid.

A probate lawyer will scrutinize the legal proceedings of the original signing ceremony to find these technical flaws.

Failure to Comply with Legal Formalities

Florida Statutes impose strict legal formalities for will execution. A valid will must be signed by the testator at the end of the document in the presence of two attesting witnesses, who must sign in the presence of each other and the testator.

Failure to observe these requirements renders the will invalid regardless of the testator’s intent.

Florida does not recognize holographic wills, which are handwritten wills signed by the testator without witnesses.

If a deceased person left only a holographic will, it cannot be admitted to probate in Florida, and the estate will pass according to intestacy laws or any valid prior instrument.

Similarly, electronic wills must comply with specific statutory requirements enacted under Florida’s Electronic Wills Act to be valid.

These requirements include proper electronic signatures and remote witnessing procedures that meet the statute’s standards. Any deviation from these legal formalities may render the instrument unenforceable.

Revocation by a Subsequent Will

If the decedent executed multiple wills, the most recent valid instrument generally controls. A later will may expressly revoke all prior wills, or its provisions may be inconsistent with earlier documents, resulting in implied revocation.

Litigation often arises when family members dispute which version of the will should govern distribution of the decedent’s estate.

When multiple wills exist, an estate planning attorney or probate litigation attorney must carefully analyze each document’s execution, timing, and revocation language.

Evidence regarding the testator’s intent, including statements made to family members or professionals, may help establish which instrument reflects the deceased person’s final wishes.

The Value of the Estate in Will Contests

The value of the estate is a pivotal consideration when deciding whether to pursue a will contest in Florida.

Under Florida law, the size and composition of the estate directly affect the potential inheritance for interested parties and can influence the overall strategy for challenging a will.

During the probate process, the estate’s assets, debts, and any exempt property are carefully evaluated to determine the net value available for distribution.

A probate attorney can help you assess the true value of the estate and weigh it against the potential costs of a will contest, including legal fees, court costs, and expert witness expenses.

In some cases, the expenses associated with a will contest may outweigh the potential recovery, especially if the estate is modest or heavily encumbered by debts.

Conversely, when significant assets are at stake, a will contest may be justified to protect your rightful share.

It’s essential for interested parties to have a clear understanding of the estate’s value before initiating a will contest. A thorough evaluation by a probate attorney can help you make an informed decision about whether to proceed, ensuring that your efforts are both financially and legally sound.

Family Relationships and Contesting a Will

Contesting a will in Florida often involves more than just legal arguments—it can deeply affect family relationships.

Family members who have legal standing, such as those named in a previous will or who would inherit under intestacy laws, may find themselves in conflict with other relatives during the legal process.

These disputes can lead to strained relationships, prolonged legal proceedings, and emotional distress for everyone involved.

A probate attorney can provide valuable guidance on navigating these sensitive family dynamics while protecting your legal rights.

They can help you understand the implications of contesting a will, including the potential for estate disputes to escalate and the impact on family harmony.

In some situations, alternative dispute resolution methods like mediation can offer a less adversarial path, allowing family members to resolve their differences without the stress and expense of a courtroom battle.

Before moving forward with a will contest, it’s important to consider not only your legal standing and the merits of your case, but also the potential long-term effects on your relationships with other family members.

An experienced probate attorney can help you weigh these factors and choose the best approach for your unique situation.

How to Challenge a Will in Florida

Step 1: Consult with a Florida Probate Litigation Attorney

Before taking any formal action, consult with an experienced attorney who handles probate litigation matters.

Your attorney will review the facts of your situation, evaluate whether you have standing to contest the will, and assess the strength of your potential claims.

Not every interested person has grounds for a viable challenge, and professional guidance early in the process can save significant time and expense.

Step 2: Gather and Review Relevant Documents

Your attorney will obtain the contested will from the probate court and review it for potential defects.

Other important documents include any previous will or codicil, trust instruments, medical records documenting the testator’s mental condition, financial statements, and correspondence that may reveal undue influence or fraud. Building a strong evidentiary foundation is essential to success.

How to Gather Evidence for a Formal Lawsuit

Filing a formal lawsuit to contest a will is a serious legal process. To succeed, the person challenging the will must gather evidence that goes beyond mere suspicion.

This often involves collecting medical records to prove a lack of capacity or financial records to demonstrate undue influence.

Your probate attorney will use the discovery phase of the probate proceedings to subpoena records and take depositions. This evidentiary foundation is what allows Florida contesting cases to move forward effectively in court.

Step 3: File a Formal Contest in Probate Court

Contesting a will in Florida requires filing a formal petition or complaint with the probate court. The filing must identify the specific legal grounds for the challenge and be submitted within the statutory deadline.

Under Florida law, an interested person typically has 90 days from service of the Notice of Administration to file objections. Missing this deadline may permanently bar your right to contest.

Step 4: Conduct Discovery and Prepare for Litigation

After filing, both sides engage in discovery to gather evidence supporting their positions. This may include depositions of witnesses who observed the testator’s condition, interrogatories seeking information from the personal representative, and requests for production of relevant documents.

Your contest lawyer will use discovery to build the strongest possible case.

Discovery often reveals critical evidence that was not apparent at the outset, including medical records, financial transactions, and communications that shed light on the circumstances surrounding the will’s execution.

The discovery phase can be extensive and is often where cases are won or lost.

Step 5: Mediation or Trial

Most Florida probate courts require or encourage mediation before trial. Mediation provides an opportunity for the involved parties to negotiate a resolution without the expense and uncertainty of litigation.

A neutral mediator facilitates discussions between family members and other interested persons, helping them reach a mutually acceptable agreement.

If mediation fails, the case proceeds to trial, where the judge will determine the will’s validity based on the evidence presented.

Trial outcomes are unpredictable, which is why many parties prefer to settle their disputes through mediation when possible.

Alternatives to Contesting a Will in Florida

While a formal will contest may be necessary in some situations, Florida law offers several alternatives for resolving estate disputes that can save time, money, and emotional energy.

Mediation is a popular option, where a neutral third party helps the parties involved reach a mutually agreeable solution without the need for a trial. This process can be especially effective in preserving family relationships and maintaining privacy.

Negotiation is another alternative, allowing parties to work directly with each other—often with the assistance of their probate attorneys—to settle disagreements over the estate.

In many cases, a settlement agreement can be reached that addresses the concerns of all interested parties, avoiding the uncertainty and expense of legal proceedings.

For smaller estates, Florida law provides for summary administration, a streamlined probate process that can expedite the distribution of assets and reduce legal fees.

A probate attorney can help you determine whether your situation qualifies for this option and guide you through the necessary steps.

Exploring these alternatives with the help of a probate attorney can often lead to more efficient and amicable resolutions to estate disputes, ensuring that the interests of all parties involved are considered.

Common Misconceptions About Contesting a Will

Many people have misconceptions about what it takes to contest a will in Florida.

One common myth is that anyone can challenge a will, but under Florida law, only interested parties with legal standing—such as heirs, beneficiaries under a previous will, or certain creditors—are permitted to bring a will contest.

Another misconception is that the process is quick and straightforward; in reality, a will contest is a complex legal proceeding that requires substantial evidence and a clear understanding of the legal grounds for contesting, such as undue influence, lack of testamentary capacity, or improper execution.

It’s also important to recognize that simply disagreeing with the contents of a will is not enough.

The person challenging the will must present substantial evidence to support their claim, whether it involves proving undue influence, demonstrating a lack of testamentary capacity, or identifying procedural errors in the will’s execution.

Legal fees and court costs can be significant, and unsuccessful challenges may further strain family relationships.

A probate attorney can help clarify these misconceptions, explain the specific legal requirements for a will contest, and assess whether you have a viable case.

Understanding the realities of the process—and the risks involved—can help you make informed decisions and avoid unnecessary legal and emotional costs.

Critical Deadlines for Will Contests in Florida

Florida imposes strict deadlines for contesting a will, and failure to act promptly can permanently eliminate your right to challenge. Generally, you must file your contest within 90 days after receiving the Notice of Administration.

In some circumstances, if formal notice is provided before probate begins, the deadline may be as short as 20 days.

An absolute bar applies after one year from service of the Notice of Administration or upon entry of the final discharge of the personal representative, whichever occurs first.

After this point, all objections are permanently barred regardless of the merits of your claim.

Because these deadlines are unforgiving, consulting with a Florida probate litigation attorney immediately upon learning of a potentially invalid will is essential.

Who Has Standing to Contest a Will in Florida?

Under state laws, only individuals with legal standing may file a will challenge. Standing typically requires that you would be affected by the outcome of the contest.

Those with standing generally include heirs at law who would inherit under intestacy if the will is invalidated, beneficiaries named in a previous will or codicil, and creditors of the decedent’s estate.

Family members who are neither heirs under intestacy nor beneficiaries under a competing instrument may lack standing to contest, regardless of their relationship to the deceased person.

An experienced attorney can evaluate your specific circumstances and determine whether you qualify as an interested person with the legal right to bring a challenge.

Understanding standing requirements early in the process prevents wasted time and resources on a contest that may be dismissed before the merits are even considered.

Why You Need a Florida Probate Litigation Attorney

Probate litigation is a specialized area of law governed by detailed procedural rules and evidentiary requirements. Attempting to contest a will without experienced legal counsel significantly reduces your chances of success and may result in costly procedural errors.

A Florida probate litigation attorney brings the knowledge and skills necessary to navigate this complex process effectively.

An estate planning attorney may prepare wills and trusts, but probate litigation requires different expertise focused on courtroom advocacy and evidence presentation.

Your attorney will analyze the will and supporting documents to identify viable legal theories and file all required pleadings within the applicable statutory deadlines.

The attorney will also conduct thorough discovery to gather evidence, retain and prepare expert witnesses, represent you in court hearings and at trial, and negotiate settlements that protect your interests.

Whether you are challenging a will or defending against a contest, skilled legal representation is essential.

Choosing the Right Attorney for Your Case

When selecting a contest lawyer, look for someone who focuses on Florida estate and probate litigation rather than general practice.

Your attorney should have trial experience and be prepared to litigate aggressively if settlement cannot be reached. Familiarity with local probate courts and judges can also provide strategic advantages.

Ask about the attorney’s experience handling cases involving undue influence claims, lack of capacity, and improper execution.

Request references or testimonials from previous clients. Transparent communication about fees, strategy, and realistic expectations is essential to a productive attorney-client relationship.

When to Hire a Florida Contest Lawyer

Not all interested parties have the same goals during probate. If you believe a will does not reflect the decedent’s true intent, you need a contest lawyer who specializes in advocacy.

A florida probate attorney can ask the court revoke a will that was improperly procured, ensuring the estate is distributed fairly.

Because the probate lawyer understands the nuances of local rules, they can help you navigate the timeline of a formal lawsuit without missing critical windows for filing.

Key Takeaways

• Contesting a will in Florida requires specific legal grounds such as undue influence, lack of capacity, fraud, or failure to comply with legal formalities.
• Florida does not recognize holographic wills, and electronic wills must meet statutory requirements to be valid.
• You must file your will challenge within 90 days of receiving the Notice of Administration, with an absolute bar after one year.
• Only an interested person with legal standing, such as heirs at law or beneficiaries under a previous will, may contest.
• Success depends on substantial evidence, experienced attorney representation, and adherence to procedural requirements.
• When multiple wills exist, litigation may focus on which instrument is valid and reflects the deceased person’s final intent.
• The cost of litigation should be weighed against the potential recovery from the decedent’s estate.
• A Florida probate litigation attorney can guide you through the process, protect your rights, and maximize your chances of success.

Contact Us Today to Learn More About Our Process Assisting Probate Clients

Contact us today to learn how our Estate Planning Law Firm guides clients through every stage of Florida Probate Law, including Contesting a Will in Florida.

A skilled Florida Probate Litigation Attorney will evaluate your Last Will and Testament for Undue Influence, Lack of Testamentary Capacity, Improper Execution, or Fraud and Forgery, and explain your legal options clearly and strategically from the outset.

If you’re contesting a Florida will or are involved in an estate matter contested in Florida, we’re here to help.

I will listen carefully to your reasons for contesting the will and provide you with the most accurate and strategic assessment possible.

Click the button below to connect with an experienced Florida probate litigation attorney who can address your legal concerns and help you with this difficult process.

We look forward to hearing from you and assisting in every way we can.